Midnight Mystery Archive

Episode 35-Lucille Butterworth

25 August 1969, Claremont, Tasmania. At 5:55 p.m. radio copy-writer and beauty-pageant finalist Lucille Butterworth waited for the city bus outside the Shalimar Hostel. Ten minutes later the shelter was empty, her evening gown never reached rehearsal, and the turquoise Holden sedan seen cruising Main Road faded into legend.

This episode retraces Lucille’s last confirmed movements, the frantic 1969 search, and the men who fell under suspicion—convicted sex-offender Geoffrey Charles Hunt and serial rapist John William Wakefield—yet were never charged. We unpack the limits of pre-DNA forensics, the 2015-16 coronial inquest that named Hunt as the probable killer, and the 2019 jailhouse confession that still wasn’t enough for prosecutors.

Fifty-five years on, Lucille’s family still searches the Derwent’s banks while investigators wait for a single piece of evidence—one that may still lie along the Lyell Highway, or in a memory that’s finally ready to be spoken.

#TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMysteries #CreepyStories #Vanished #MidnightMysteryArchive #MissingPerson #unsolved #coldcasefiles #unsolvedcase #creepystories #Australia

• William
• jared K
• Lisa Mooney
• Jamie Mcconnell